RKWare.com
Just another WordPress weblog

I really want to know how product recalls work. I want to know how much budget the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission gets every year to spend to “protect” us as consumers. And, if you can put a dollar on it, I’d love to know how much businesses have to spent to comply with needless regulations.

First off, let me say that we all agree that death is tragic, especially the accidental death of a child. But, the world isn’t perfect… horrible things will continue to happen no matter how carefully you live your life.

With that said, you may have heard of the recent product recall of 2.1 million cribs. I expected these to be the equivalent of bag of broken glass (Grr NBC for not allowing classic SNL clips to be on youtube, but that’s a different rant!), but come on. Let me point out some facts about these “death traps”.

  • 2.1 Million of these items were sold.
  • Only 4 deaths are linked to this crib.
  • This Deadly Device was on the market for 17 and a half years before anyone noticed.
  • The crib is only harmful when its improperly assembled by adults who don’t follow the clear warnings in the instructions!!

Many of these were used by multiple children within one household, and many were likely sold to other people, so there are MANY more then just 2.1 Million children who used these cribs. So, a conservative estimate with round numbers would be, 4 deaths in 2 Million uses over 17 years. That’s a 0.0002% failure rate with one death every 4.25 years.  Really?! Keep in mind that the chance of being struck by lightning is 0.000357%. So, you’re twice as likely to be struck by lightning then to die in one of these cribs. (Many assumptions in those calculations, but you get the point.)

I have no doubt that the people who are crusading to protect us innocent consumers think that they are doing nobel work, but really!? I mean come on. I’d love to be able to follow the money further to see where their salaries are paid and how they choose what products to go after. A “non-profit” organization was on Chicago’s news coverage of the story… I’d love to find out how much they receive in donations and how much of that goes to pay internal costs, like salaries.

Good to know that our government is busy trying to keep us safe. They even have a twitter account. I really feel sorry for the poor soul that has to do that for a living (and how much are they paid to do that?).

  • Share/Bookmark

Tags: , , ,

2 Tweets

5 Comments

  1. Michael Hudec says:

    Perhaps they should recall lightning instead? >:)

  2. RyanK says:

    Its a complete coincidence that there’s lightning in the theme now and that I referenced getting struck by lightning, but I’m guessing that its an improvement! I figured it was better then the white on dark, but not completely happy with it yet! But yeah, wouldn’t be surprised if someone tried to make it illegal to get struck by lightning!

    Was actually wondering what you thought about the recall, given that you are both a parent and an engineer. I’ve often been told that my opinion would change if I had kids!

  3. Michael Hudec says:

    I know it’s rare, but I totally agree with you. Horrible things happen, but the math doesn’t lie. The cost of protecting everyone from everything is too high of a price to burden society with. I’m sure the parents of the 4 kids that perished would argue otherwise, but 4 of 12 million is statistically insignificant. Actually, I’m surprised that the number is so low for Any product. It seems that every other toy my kid touches has parts that break off and can be dangerous if stupidity is added into the mix. The argument against the cribs style is that the fold down part inherently causes issues. I think there would be at least 4 kids that would get dropped by parents who physically couldn’t lift their child into a regular crib. (ie mom’s right after c section cant do the up & over thing with the older sibling.) You simply can’t make the would perfectly safe, regardless of the price.

Post Comment

Please notice: Comments are moderated by an Admin.

Additional comments powered by BackType


Powered by Wordpress
Theme © 2005 - 2009 FrederikM.de
BlueMod is a modification of the blueblog_DE Theme by Oliver Wunder